9th Circuit rules work practice apprentice at Zen Buddhist temple subject to ministerial exemption: Behrend v. San Francisco Zen Center, Inc.

In Behrend v. San Francisco Zen Center, Inc., (9th Cir.)           F.3d           (Jul. 18, 2024), the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that a work practice apprentice at a Buddhist temple was subject to the ministerial exception, barring his ADA claim for disability discrimination.

Read more

Plaintiff, who had disabilities, was accepted into Defendant’s work practice apprentice (WPA) program, which provided room and board and a stipend in exchange for work duties. After experiencing PTSD symptoms and requesting accommodations, Plaintiff was terminated. He sued under the ADA, and the district court granted summary judgment for Defendant, applying the ministerial exception. Plaintiff appealed.

On appeal, the Ninth Circuit affirmed. It held that the ministerial exception applies not only to religious leaders and teachers, but also to those performing vital religious functions, citing Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & Sch. v. EEOC (2012) 565 U.S. 171.  Because Plaintiff performed “vital religious duties” as part of the WPA program, including assisting with rituals and participating in meditations, he qualified for the exception. The court rejected Plaintiff’s argument that his mostly menial work disqualified him from the exception.

Full opinion

Scroll to Top