Court of Appeal holds no new 65-day waiting period required for amended PAGA notices: Brown v. Dave & Buster’s of California

In Brown v. Dave & Buster’s of California (2025) 116 Cal. App. 5th 164, the Court of Appeal (Second Appellate District, Division Eight) held that a PAGA plaintiff need not wait 65 days after amending a pre-filing notice before amending a complaint to add new claims or defendants. 

Plaintiff filed a standalone PAGA action for wage and hour violations, which was stayed due to a previously filed identical action (Espinoza). After Defendant settled a related PAGA matter (Andrade), Defendant moved for judgment on the pleadings, arguing the Andrade settlement barred Plaintiff’s claims. Plaintiff opposed, arguing Andrade failed to exhaust administrative remedies because only 35 days (not the statutory 65) elapsed between Andrade’s amended LWDA notice (adding vacation pay claims and new defendants) and the filing of her amended complaint. The trial court granted the motion and dismissed Plaintiff’s complaint with prejudice.

The Court of Appeal affirmed the dismissal. It first noted that Plaintiff conceded, by omission in her opening brief, that the Andrade settlement was a final judgment on the merits covering her non-vacation pay claims. On the exhaustion issue, the court held that neither the PAGA statute nor case law explicitly mandates a new 65-day waiting period for amended notices and complaints. The court found persuasive federal district court decisions that declined to strictly enforce pre-filing timelines and noted their consistency with the doctrine of substantial compliance. It distinguished LaCour v. Marshalls of California (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 1172, noting that unlike in LaCour, the claims in Andrade’s notice were not completely distinct from the claims in the original notice. Given that Plaintiff “substantially fulfilled the purpose of the

PAGA pre-filing notice requirement in her amended notice”, the failure to wait 65 days was therefore a “harmless defect”. 

Full opinion

Scroll to Top